Pedro Pascal Makes His Oscar Case With ‘Behemoth!’: A Career-Defining Performance at New York Film Festival

When Pedro Pascal walks onto a film set these days, he brings an entire internet’s worth of adoration with him. The “Daddy” memes, the Game of Thrones legacy, the Mandalorian helmet, the Last of Us heartbreak — they all precede him. But at Alice Tully Hall on Friday night, as Tony Gilroy’s Behemoth! unspooled as the centerpiece selection of the 63rd New York Film Festival, something different happened. The noise fell away. What remained was a man with a cello, a lifetime of scars, and a performance so quietly devastating that it may finally force the Academy to look past the phenomenon and see the actor.

From Internet Boyfriend to Awards Contender: Pascal’s Long Road to This Moment

Pascal was nearly 40 when Oberyn Martell’s venomous charm exploded across Game of Thrones in 2014. The character’s brutal exit became one of television’s most talked-about deaths, but it also launched a career trajectory few saw coming: Narcos, The Mandalorian, The Last of Us. Along the way, Pascal became something rare — a leading man who arrived fully formed in middle age, bypassing the typical Hollywood gestation period.

Yet the very visibility that made him a cultural staple also created a paradox. The thirst tweets and “internet boyfriend” discourse threatened to obscure the craft. His scene-stealing turn as Javi in The Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent (2022) — holding his own against Nicolas Cage at his most unhinged — went largely unrewarded come awards season. Projects with Pedro Almodóvar (Strange Way of Life), Celine Song (Materialists), and Ari Aster (Eddington) showcased range, but none built a film entirely around what Pascal does when nobody’s talking.

Behemoth! changes that equation entirely.

Inside ‘Behemoth!’: A Cellist’s Reckoning With the Ghosts of Hollywood’s Scoring Stages

Gilroy’s first directorial effort since The Bourne Legacy (2012) centers on Alex Serian (Pascal), a former child prodigy from a dynasty of Los Angeles studio musicians who fled the industry 20 years earlier. He returns to record film scores, and each session triggers a flood of memory. The structure is elegantly simple: Alex sits down to play a cue, the music transports him backward, and we witness the fractures — with his father (Hank Azaria), his brother (Will Arnett), the woman he couldn’t keep (Olivia Wilde) — that drove him away.

Pascal barely speaks during these flashback sequences. He doesn’t need to. The performance lives in micro-adjustments: the tightening of a jaw, the hesitation before bow meets string, the way his shoulders carry decades of unresolved grief. It’s acting of the highest order — internalized, muscular, and utterly devoid of theatricality.

Tony Gilroy’s Musical Architecture: Nine Composers, One Stunning Soundtrack

If Pascal is the film’s soul, the music is its heartbeat. Gilroy recruited nine composers to score the fictional films within Behemoth! — a meta-concept that could have felt gimmicky but instead achieves something remarkable. The roster reads like a Film Music Hall of Fame ballot: Michael Giacchino (Up, Oscar winner), James Newton Howard (Michael Clayton, nine-time nominee, zero wins), Alan Silvestri (Forrest Gump, Back to the Future, also never won), Michael Abels (Get Out), Henry Jackman (Captain America: The Winter Soldier), Brandon Roberts (Andor), Emily Bear, Lukas Frank, and Nami Melumad (Pixar’s Dream Productions).

The soundtrack moves across eras and genres with the same fluidity as Alex’s memory. It’s a love letter to the Los Angeles scoring community — the musicians, orchestrators, and engineers whose work defines cinema’s emotional vocabulary but rarely receives spotlight. Gilroy, who collaborated with Howard on Michael Clayton and Roberts on Andor, understands this world intimately.

Olivia Wilde’s Career-Best Work: Channeling Cameron Diaz in ‘Vanilla Sky’

Pascal isn’t the only revelation. Olivia Wilde, coming off a knockout year directing and starring in The Invite and reminding audiences of her dangerous allure in I Want Your Sex, delivers what may be her finest screen performance. As the ex-partner Alex can’t shake, Wilde taps into something raw and frightening — a woman whose love has curdled into obsession. The comparison to Cameron Diaz in Vanilla Sky is apt: both performances weaponize beauty to mask something unhinged underneath. Diaz earned Golden Globe and SAG nominations for that role; the Academy overlooked her. Wilde deserves better.

The Oscar History No One Talks About: 75 Years Since a Latino Won Best Actor

Behemoth! premiered during Hispanic Heritage Month, and the timing carries weight. Look at the record: José Ferrer (Puerto Rican) won Best Actor for Cyrano de Bergerac in 1950. He remains the only Latino to do so. Anthony Quinn (Mexican) won two Supporting Oscars but lost Lead for Wild Is the Wind and Zorba the Greek. Edward James Olmos (Stand and Deliver), Demián Bichir (A Better Life), Colman Domingo (Rustin, Sing Sing), and most recently Wagner Moura (first Brazilian nominee, for The Secret Agent) all came close. The drought spans three-quarters of a century.

Pascal, born in Chile and raised in the U.S., carries that history whether he wants to or not. His performance in Behemoth! — restrained, intellectual, deeply felt — recalls Jude Law in Cold Mountain: a reserved turn that survived an Oscar season typically biased toward showiness. Law’s Inman barely spoke during his walk home from the Civil War; voters noticed anyway. Pascal’s war is internal, but the wounds are no less visible.

A Crowded Field: The 99th Academy Awards Best Actor Race Takes Shape

Pascal enters a formidable conversation. John Leguizamo, honored with the Career Achievement Award at the Critics Choice Celebración the same day as the Behemoth! premiere, is generating serious buzz for Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey — his first Oscar nomination after four decades of groundbreaking work. Colman Domingo could return for a third consecutive nomination. Timothée Chalamet (Marty Supreme), Leonardo DiCaprio (The Wager), and Adam Driver (Anniversary) all have high-profile vehicles. The category is deep.

But Pascal has something few competitors possess: a film that’s explicitly about the anatomy of performance. Behemoth! understands that acting, like music, lives in the spaces between notes. The Academy’s music branch — which now allows up to three composers per score nomination — faces its own irony: nine composers contributed to Behemoth!, and unless they enter as a “group” (sharing a single statuette), the category’s rules may exclude them. A movie about musicians, shut out of the category built for them.

Release Strategy and Awards Calendar: What Comes Next

Searchlight Pictures opens Behemoth! in limited release on December 4, 2025, with wide expansion through December — perfectly positioned for Oscar eligibility and peak awards-season visibility. The film’s NYFF centerpiece slot signals studio confidence; recent centerpiece selections like The Fabelmans (2022) and Nickel Boys (2024) translated into major nominations.

The film won’t be for everyone. Its Tár-adjacent DNA — a protagonist whose genius and damage spring from the same source — may alienate viewers wanting conventional payoff. The “fake movie” conceit risks preciousness. The climax goes small, deliberately. But underneath Gilroy’s brilliant screenplay beats a simple, aching idea: love, and what we delude ourselves into believing we’re owed.

Key Details at a Glance

Why This Matters Beyond Awards Season

“We must sit still and hold the note for Pedro.” That final line from the festival review captures something essential. Pascal’s journey — from Chilean refugee parents to Game of Thrones breakout to this moment — mirrors the film’s central tension: the gap between who we were and who we become, and whether the music we make along the way can ever fully bridge it.

Whether Behemoth! translates festival heat into Oscar gold remains unwritten. But Pascal has already accomplished something rarer than a nomination: he’s made a film that demands to be listened to, not just watched. In an industry that increasingly mistakes volume for vitality, that’s its own kind of triumph.

Arts, Entertainment, News, People, Film, Awards Season, Academy Awards, Oscars, Pedro Pascal, Tony Gilroy, Olivia Wilde, New York Film Festival, Hispanic Heritage Month, Latino Representation, Film Music, Searchlight Pictures, 2025 Films, Best Actor Predictions